The US House is in disarray following
Kevin McCarthy's loss of speaker votes.
Republican
leader Kevin McCarthy failed repeatedly in his bid to be elected Speaker of the
US House of Representatives on a day of political drama unprecedented in
Congress in a century.
The House
adjourned without a speaker on Tuesday night, the first time since 1923 that a
first-round vote failed to elect a leader.
The start of
a new Congress was supposed to be a victory lap for the Republican Party, which
had taken control of the lower chamber following the elections in November.
Instead, McCarthy faced internal opposition and made history for all the wrong
reasons.
So far, the
California congressman has lost three consecutive votes for Speaker, and it's
unclear what his path to victory will be when the House reconvenes on
Wednesday. They will vote until someone obtains a majority.
Even if Mr
McCarthy finds a way, analysts warn that the turmoil on the House floor
foreshadows a tumultuous two years of conflict between moderate and right-wing
Republicans.
Negotiations made him appear weak.'
Republicans
narrowly won control of the House in November, so McCarthy only needed a few
votes to become Speaker. As a result, a group of staunch conservatives banded
together to oppose his nomination.
Republican observers say the schism
was a long time coming.
"For a
long time, Kevin McCarthy has not made friends with certain segments of the
caucus; he's made a lot of enemies," said one Republican lobbyist, who
requested anonymity to speak candidly about Tuesday's vote. "There are
people who dislike him for political and personal reasons."
Mr McCarthy
entered into talks with his critics, who see him as too mainstream and power
hungry, offering concessions in an attempt to win their support. At one point,
he reportedly agreed to change House rules to make it easier to remove a
sitting Speaker, effectively limiting his power.
"The
fact that he was negotiating with Republicans at all made him look very, very
weak, almost desperate," a Republican lobbyist said.
His opponents are encouraged.
On Tuesday,
the futility of that approach became clear.
Mr McCarthy
failed to reach the required 218 vote threshold three times in a row. Despite
the fact that Republicans hold 222 seats, a group of 19 hard-right Republicans
had banded together to oppose him. They oppose McCarthy on ideological and
personal grounds, but they also see an opportunity to use Republicans' narrow
majority to force him to make additional concessions.
They would
"never back down," Virginia Republican Representative Rob Good told
reporters on Tuesday.
They even
nominated Representative Jim Jordan to challenge him in one of the day's most
dramatic moments, just moments after Mr Jordan himself nominated Mr McCarthy
for Speaker.
Even after
Mr Jordan, a prominent member of the hard-right Freedom Caucus, urged
Republicans to "rally around" Mr McCarthy in the third round of
voting, 20 Republicans voted for Mr Jordan, denying Mr McCarthy victory yet
again.
Meanwhile,
Democrats remained united behind their party's new leader, New York
Representative Hakeem Jeffries.
A few
couldn't help but poke fun at their Republican counterparts' difficult
afternoon. One Arizona congressman, Ruben Gallego, tweeted that Democrats were
"breaking out the popcorn," and included a photo of the snack as
proof.
What are McCarthy's next steps?
Political
observers in Washington have begun to concoct various scenarios for how this
could all end. Their predictions to the BBC ranged from the plausible (Mr
McCarthy holds out and wins, but walks away severely weakened) to the entirely
plausible (Mr McCarthy holds out and wins, but walks away severely weakened)
(he bows out and backs his second in command, Representative Steve Scalise of
Louisiana). One suggestion bordered on the fantastical (five Republicans decide
to vote for Mr Jeffries, a Democrat, and deliver him control of the House). McCarthy
is currently "essentially hostage to one side of his party,"
according to Ruth Bloch Rubin, a political scientist who studies partisanship
at the University of Chicago.
Mr McCarthy
has pledged not to make any more concessions, but he may be forced to. He could
try to persuade obstinate lawmakers with prestigious committee assignments or
new leadership positions.
"He's
got to give the people who are against him something to hang their hat
on," said Aaron Cutler, a lobbyist who previously worked for former
congressman Eric Cantor, another politician ousted by conservative opposition.
The other Republican lobbyist, on the other hand, believed there was "no path
to victory, period."
Members will
meet for the fourth time on Wednesday, but it's unclear whether the impasse
will be broken.
"We
haven't heard anything new from McCarthy," said Representative Lauren
Boebert of Colorado, one of the conservative holdouts. "I suppose we'll
just keep doing it."
No comments:
Post a Comment